Isn’t Stupid a Bad Word?

February 4, 2009 by Kailani  
Filed under random thoughts

Well, it is in my home as I’m sure it is in most others. So why do supposedly G-rated cartoons and movies use this word like it’s not a big deal? I just don’t understand the rationale behind it when they could have easily used “silly” or “crazy” and still make the same point.

Just wondering . . .

About the Author: Kailani:
Owner of An Island Life. A flight attendant and mother to 3 beautiful girls. . . living a blessed life in Hawaii.
Share and Enjoy:
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • Kirtsy
  • Technorati
  • LinkedIn
Photobucket

Comments

57 Responses to “Isn’t Stupid a Bad Word?”
  1. 1
    Mozi Esme's Mommy says:

    good question. got no answers for you!

    Reply
  2. 2
    Amy @ Coffee with the Mrs. says:

    I get irritated at the same sort of thing. I was watching Ice Age 2 with my son and turned it off immediately when they used the word “crap”. I couldn’t believe my ears! There’s no good reason for using words like that in a kid’s movie. rar.

    Reply
    • 2.1
      FourthDimensional says:

      It was “crab”…

      Reply
    • 2.2
      ILovePuppies99 says:

      I agree! I would turn off a kid’s movie using the word “crap”. That’s the C-word. There’s no good reason for using the C-word in a kid’s movie, darn.
      I would tell the baby, Julia Jane Kuraki, “You can say crud, but you are not allowed to say the C word.”
      If baby Julia Kuraki is frustrated with her stuff, she can say, “Darn!” or “This thing is so stupid!” but she can’t say the C word.

      Reply
  3. 3
    Erin says:

    I could not agree more. Now I understand the appeal of Barney, it’s about the only place you know you won’t run into that. So many non-cuss words that are tossed around as ‘okay’, if you’re angry, in movies and TV. No wonder so many kids have potty mouths by third grade.

    Reason number 367 that I homeschool . . . :-)
    ~Erin

    Reply
  4. 4
    Kristi says:

    A GREAT BID AAAAMMMMEEEEENNNNNNN!!! (that’s Amen if you can’t read it. A few weeks ago I started WWIII in my family because I said I avoid Disney movies. It’s largely because THAT word is everywhere in them.

    Reply
  5. 5
    Teri says:

    We try to avoid that word at our house too. And I also don’t know why they put it in movies and tv – not cool!

    Reply
    • 5.1
      Usuf says:

      ashley fennell – drea! you made me laugh! i was bored in class so i thhgout id stalk the blog page and what do i find? lol yeah regaurdless i chuckled quietly to myself. thanks it was enjoyable! andi havent even listened to the actual blog yet. lol

      Reply
    • 5.2
      Adam says:

      I’m imsdseper. You’ve really raised the bar with that.

      Reply
    • 5.3
      Ajin says:

      ck I agree what you think. When I read the news, I kept asking mylesf to define those descriptive words. What does ‘brainwash’ mean to u? It sounds pretty negative, but in my mind it is a pure manipulation game. Who ever could think of an effective way to manipulate how other thinks, I think that’s an act of brainwashing. Advertisements do that to us so everyday, and that is the ultimate aim of an advert; people argue with their partner to get ur point across everyday in order to have the same mind;.. etc. This is how people get a point across. I guess the problem is not about who’s being brainwashed/manipulated, its the fact that people getting manipulated only because they don’t really think, they choose to believe in something appeared to be easiest to believe. Students are the easy targets as they lack of life experience; that’s why their conclusion of their views does not sound convincing.. look at their arguements. My view is, I’m not a big fan of being told what’s right and wrong. U will never feel it until u experienced the benefits or the harm that u tasted. I believe it is the only way to tell right from wrong.. etc Even i dont have a child, I know how easy children could be manipulated/brainwashed.. it is hard to support either “side” if theres only “black and white”; thats why i dont like politics, it eats ur mind up. In addition, i think if gov insist on ??????, they should compromise by making the material totally neutral: pick out all the ‘potential influensive words/sentance’ and remove all the views in the material. I believe information/knowledge can always be neutral. if a positive arguement has to be made, make sure an equally negative arguement on the other side has to be present to balance out. This could be done by hiring auditor to summerize the material in a quantatative way, then use some statistical methods to assess the teaching material. Regards, statistician

      Reply
  6. 6
    Desert Songbird says:

    I’ve had that same thought many times myself.

    Reply
  7. 7
    jodi @ bpr says:

    I am so with you there! I often wonder if those people even think!

    Reply
  8. 8
    Queen-sized funny bone says:

    Many times when I even hear a F bomb or excessive swearing I wonder how do they think this made the movie better?

    Reply
  9. 9
    Autumn @ My MoonBean says:

    This is something I have recently been hit in the face with. Words that I never considered as “bad” but when you hear your 2 year old say them, it’s totally HORRIBLE! I think it’s all about perspective, and the writers don’t always consider which ears are hearing it! I know I am definitely trying to improve my vocab :)

    Reply
    • 9.1
      Marcela says:

      An impressive share, I just given this onto a colaelgue who was performing a bit analysis on this. And he in actual fact bought me breakfast for the reason that I identified it for him.. smile. So let me reword that: Thnx for the treat! But yeah Thnkx for spending the time to talk about this, I feel strongly about it and enjoy reading a lot more on this subject. If achievable, as you become expertise, would you mind updating your weblog with alot more details? It can be highly useful for me. Huge thumb up for this weblog post!

      Reply
  10. 10
    Jennifer says:

    Excellent question. It is not allowed in our home. As for TV, since we rarely watch it I have not encountered it on Telly yet there a re a lot of things that IMO should not be allowed on telly, which is one of many reasons we do not watch it unless it is NOVA or a documentary.

    Reply
  11. 11
    Qtpies7 says:

    Yeah, it is sad. But kids do have to learn about words that are not OK to say some time. And that is a better word to learn on than the F word, LOL.
    I just wish that kids shows were FOR kids, and not geared to adults. I don’t like seeing movies with adult innuendos in them that are marketed to kids. Like Shrek.

    Reply
  12. 12
    AmyG says:

    It’s not a nice word here, either. I try hard not to say it. And we’ve stopped watching Zack & Cody, Hannah Montana & all the other Disney shows that we’ve come to love, because of that one word. They say it so much. If one of us slips & says it… both my girls will say, “you said a bad word”. Sometimes I have to stop to think what I said, because I’m thinking, “I did??” lol

    Reply
  13. 13
    Cathi says:

    My grandson loved watching Sponge Bob until his little brother started calling people “idiot”.
    No more Sponge Bob.
    I think the creators of these shows think it’s cute to hear little ones say words they shouldn’t.

    Reply
  14. 14
    Kim @ What's That Smell? says:

    Oh I know! Just when we got Jake to start replacing it with “silly” yet another cartoon or movie (g-rated) says it and we start right back at the beginning.

    Saying stupid in our house gets one sent to ones room around here.

    Reply
  15. 15
    Lori Downs says:

    wish I had an asnwer I would love to know but here is another question why does burger king get to use the word Virgin? and how mnay kids ask thier parents what a virgin is

    Reply
  16. 16
    Naomi says:

    Mean-ness sucks. Oops, sucks is another sketchy one. I think the best thing is just to teach your kids appropriateness. Sometimes things that seem innocuous in one contest are totally wrong in another and that is one of the most important rules a parent can pass on to their kids…

    Then again, I hate hearing people over 40 call the f-word “the f- word” if you know what I mean. In the end, a word is just a word. I saw Gran Torino last week and had never heard half of the derogatory slang for Asians, for example. If you don’t take it that way, it can’t hurt you, right?

    Reply
  17. 17
    Mary @ Holy Mackerel says:

    I agree. Not only with that word, but so many inappropriate things on during the day when all children are up, and many planted in front of the television babysitter.

    Reply
  18. 18
    Monkey! says:

    Isn’t “stupid” better than “retard” or any 4-letter word? My godson is learning words now so i’m being charged $5 for every cuss word that comes out my mouth. Helluva trust fund already!

    Reply
  19. 19
    Holly Schwendiman says:

    Combating the outside influence is HUGE. These little things add up and really helped push me over the edge for removing TV from my home.

    Hugs,
    Holly

    Reply
  20. 20
    Jennifer says:

    Stupid is a bad word in our house. We just never say it. We taught my daughter it was wrong and mentioned some of the alternatives you said. If she hears it on a show, she always makes a point of they should have said silly or goofy.

    Reply
  21. 21
    Muthering Heights says:

    It seems that there are more and more things permissible across the whole rating scale anymore!

    Reply
  22. 22
    Ann says:

    We were not able to use that word growing up…it still makes me turn my head when I hear someone say it. I do not like it!

    Reply
  23. 23
    Renee says:

    seems to me that the entire industry is just trying really hard for us all to shut the tv off!

    I’m appalled by what is either on the show or in the commericals all day long. It is getting so that you can’t even allow your child to watch a supposed channel that is just for kids. CLICK!

    I’m just so glad that DD would rather play or read a book than watch. when we do watch…it’s the food network! LOL! One day my child will be a great chef.

    Reply
  24. 24
    Deb - Mom of 3 Girls says:

    Oh I hate this too! Thankfully my girls know it’s a ‘bad’ word so they don’t repeat it even after hearing it in a movie – but it would be so much easier if we didn’t have to worry about it to begin with. I hate the idea of limiting them just based on whether or not ‘stupid’ is used, especially if it’s a really good movie otherwise. But it’s so frustrating!

    Reply
  25. 25
    Noreen says:

    we were watching bug’s life yesterday and my daughter pointed out that hopper uses stupid and that it is a bad word. I read an article in a parents magazine once and it read that silly was a bad word which is silly to me, which is why I used it in the name of my blog, I like silly but not stupid.

    Reply
  26. 26
    Baba says:

    I totally agree! We try to teach our children not to say that word and yet they see it all the time. It undermines our efforts.

    Reply
  27. 27
    Stacey says:

    I posted about this issue too. I just don’t understand why they can’t have the cartoon character use less “offensive” words. I’m not saying to make everything happy and merry and full of big fluffy clouds and rainbows. But I do have a problem with cartoon characters (designed for toddlers and pre-schoolers) calling each other stupid or jerks.

    Reply
  28. 28
    Heather says:

    Okay, so I’m not okay with words like “stupid” or “crap” on children’s television. However, something that has really gotten under my skin lately is Swiper on Dora the Explorer. For some reason, I’m really annoyed by the fact that they want my son to repeat the words “Swiper, stop swiping!” … He’s 3-ish. I doubt we really need to start giving lessons on theft at this age- let alone introducing lingo like ‘swiping’.

    Reply
  29. 29
    Donna@WayMoreHomemade says:

    Even for me, stupid, when in reference to a person is off limits. And, since my philosophy with my kids is to set the boundaries tightly at first and then broaden them as they mature, certain words are off limits 100% of the time right now. “Stupid” is one of them. So is “butt” and “booty” though. I think we have to be realistic in that as they age they will say words like this, but I feel it is inappropriate (in my home at least) for toddlers and preschoolers up through elementary age. (I posted about this topic recently.)

    Reply
  30. 30
    Heather says:

    I have some old Care Bears videos that were made and shown when I was a kid. They use stupid and idiot and more in there. I don’t care for teaching very young children to call other people stupid, but I guess I’d rather have that be a teaching moment at home about how to treat people (or not treat people) than to have them hear it for the first time and have no idea what to say.

    Reply
  31. 31
    Sarah Jewel says:

    I don’t feel it’s a “bad word” but I think it gets used inappropriately far too often. I don’t have a problem with innanimate objects being called stupid, but if it comes to people being called stupid, I tend to want to stop that, as it’s just a mean comment.

    Reply
  32. 32
    Lori says:

    one of the students at my school came up to me and whispered, “chelsea said the ‘s’ word!” we were justifiably concerned .. until we found out the ‘s’ word was ‘stupid’. ;^)

    a lot of teachers make a big fuss out of kids saying someone else is stupid or calling themselves stupid .. makes sense, i suppose, if you are trying to convince them that they can grow as learners.

    Reply
  33. 33
    Gennaro says:

    It’s definately a bit much for a cartoon. As you mentioned, there are other options.

    Reply
  34. 34
    Just Mom says:

    Sometimes I think Disney and other studios that make movies targeted to kids, should have parents sit in and advise them about the kind of words the characters use. Some of the words I heard recently while watching a Disney film for kids were “stupid,” “moron” and “idiot.”

    Reply
  35. 35
    ciara says:

    i think there are words far worse than stupid though it’s not nice to call someone that. my kids are older so they know better. there are words that i will not tolerate though. you can do only so much to protect your kids from words or things you don’t like or approve of, but when they go to school, it’s a whole new ball game. i may get flak, but i keep things realistic…i have open door policy and kids can talk to me about whatever they need.

    Reply
  36. 36
    Jeannie says:

    I agree with you!!!!!! TV is NOT liek it use to be when we were growing up!!!! Soooooooooooooooooooooo much has changed!!!! I think that is part of the reason kids act the way they do….TV…the Disney Chan…those kids on their are little smart butts!!!!!!

    Reply
  37. 37
    thefarmerfiles says:

    We pretty much stick to PBS kids for just this reason.

    Reply
  38. 38
    Pamela says:

    because our culture IS getting stupid.
    things have changed so much even since I was a kid.
    Now I know how my folks felt.

    Reply
  39. 39
    MommyAmy says:

    I agree.

    But, I dislike the use of Shut Up even more.

    Reply
  40. 40
    Cat @ 3 Kids and Us says:

    With all of the bad words my kids could be saying, “stupid” is one we let slide, unless they are directly calling a person that.

    Reply
  41. 41
    kris says:

    I think there are worse things a person can say. In our house, you cannot call a PERSON stupid but using the word itself is okay. Silly and crazy are not the same thing and don’t work in some situations. We are also not allowed to tell another person to shut-up and there are many times that I tell my children that there are better words that they could use. Most times that is enough. We have two grown children and I can tell you that the way they talk will directly be reflected by the words we use to them and the friends that they hang out with each day!

    Reply
  42. 42
    Debbie says:

    I am a 59 year old grandmother and a mother of a 14 year old. I never, and mean never, heard anyone ever say stupid was a bad word when I was growing up. Sorry, but I don’t agree with you. Sometimes there is no substitute for the word stupid. Humans can do stupid things, but that does not mean you should call them stupid. Taking drugs is a stupid action, driving under the inflluence of alcohol is a stupid action. What would you think of me as a nurse if I said ,”taking drugs is silly”? Kinda looses its punch, don’t ya think?
    Same thing with shut up. Shut means to close. If I said close your mouth or shut your mouth, why is one worse than the other? Adding the world up does not make it worse! Sorry, you guys are zeroing in on ” silly” things.

    Reply
    • 42.1
      Pam says:

      I know this post is old, but I had to reply to Debbie. THANK YOU! I am your age and I agree with you. The other day I was chatting with a group of people, including a woman and her 8-year-old. I was telling a story about something that I had done as a teenager that had turned out to be a really (dare I say it?) “stupid” decision. You’d think I had said the most foul word possible. Both of them rudely chastised me in front of everyone, making me feel (here comes the bad word again) stupid. Replacing the word “stupid” with the word “silly” just doesn’t work. My teenaged decision was not “silly” and their holier-than-thou rudeness towards me certainly was not “silly”. It was mean.

      Reply
    • 42.2
      Hannah Kim says:

      I agree! This bag is so stupid, but that does not mean you should call someone stupid. How about if I was coaching six-year-old female skaters and one naughty six-year-old used her iPod? I’d tell THAT kindergartner, “Put your phone away! I am not that stupid! Now!”
      What if that same six-year-old was not listening and I said, “That’s my way of telling you to shut up!” I do not call out people’s names because I do not wish to embarrass them, but I will use words that punch verbally if I need to.

      Reply
  43. 43
    I Should Have My Mouth Washed Out With Soap | Hey Lady! Whatcha Readin'? says:

    [...] writing this, I found a post where many parents (I assume) weighed in on the word stupid. I don’t think that stupid is a bad word…it’s all in the way your kid uses it, [...]

    Reply
  44. 44
    Alfred says:

    I don’t see how words can be bad, especially one like stupid. I think americans need to grow up on this matter, this aint the middle ages anymore.

    Reply
  45. 45
    Steph says:

    Well when i was in elementary school, i had already heard the word stupid, and i knew that it wasn’t really a “bad word” like the four letter unmentionables, it just was not a good word for me to say. Kinda like the word butt: I knew it obviously was not a “bad” word, it just often wasn’t very appropriate… I never really said “stupid” or “butt” or other words like that at all in elementary. I’m 16 right now, and cursing has not once come out of my mouth. I’d have more of a problem with words like crap, crud, retarded, stupid, or idiot being used around a little kid. Plus, if you tell your kids that stupid is never really a good word to say, then it makes for a good learning experience for the child, and while they might hear the word “stupid”, they’ll know it’s not the word for them!
    And last but not least, I 100% agree about shrek and ice age being a little too much for kids… Ice Age used the word crap, crud, and even wild ass for crying out loud!!!
    (I cannot believe i just wrote that insanely stupid.. err.. SILLY comment.)

    Reply
  46. 46
    Sakura98 says:

    Yes, this is sad. This is NOT a better word to use than the F word or the C word. I used the C word “Crap” “Crud” “Cripple” “Crippled” “Fat” “Retarded” “Midget “Gay” and the F word “f-u-c-k” and “h-e-l-l” until I paid the price. This was a price too high to pay. So iI learned, ‘Never swear.’ With all these bad words, “s-t-u-p-i-d” is one we let slide, unless we are calling someone the “S” word or using it of a guitar or something.
    Sakura98: I know most people would think the website was completely stupid.

    Reply
  47. 47
    Sakura98 says:

    At “Karate Kid” when they said the bad word “c-r-a-p” and “c-r-u-d” I didn’t like it because of Jaden Smith’s disruptive behavior and cussing. If I was the attractive, slanted-eyed woman near the little boy, I’d teach him [NOT PUNISH HIM BECAUSE HE DIDN'T KNOW ANY BETTER], “Where are your manners? Be a nice boy, young man! Look what you did! This is BAD, young man and you know this is not good social skills. I’m going to use my hand to use consequences. How old are you? The only way you are acting is like a five-year-old, young man! Now apologize or you are taking time-away somewhere lousy with me while I teach you but in reality you gonna be without help. Dre, where are your manners, young man?”
    “Im sorry” he’d say because of his disruptive behavior and bad words.
    Youth movies are too much for them like in manga Sonic X one of the nice girls [not Amy, but Wave] spoke to Sonic “Im gonna burn you alive!”
    Manga is too much for youth because of how manga ‘LL BE GOOD.
    THE PROPER WORDS JADEN SMITH COULD’VE USED SHOULD HAVE BEEN “OH GREAT I STINK AT THIS”.

    Reply
  48. 48
    Sakura98 says:

    I know that most people would think that the website was completely stupid.
    This is kind of a bad word but this is not a good word. Whoever said this is not a bad word DOESN’T KNOW ANY BETTER.
    Why do G or PG or PG-13 rated movies use such bad words? Saying the “S” word stupid and the “C” word “you are so crazy” are BAD WORDS, BAD WORDS, BAD WORDS, BAD WORDS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    Positive, Effective Consequences:
    NO TATTLING [WITH THE EXCEPTION OF TELLING [DANGEROUS OR DESTRUCTIVE]]
    NO BEING SMUG
    NO CUSSING
    NO HURTING PEOPLE’S FEELINGS
    Stopping tattling: Start by putting him taking time-away for 2 hours as consequence for disruptive behavior after he apologizes. In the classroom, time-away is on the wall where the tail is for 2 HOURS in front of the other youth, because time-away is positive, effective consequence. In the lunchroom or something, make him apologize, write his name [put his name on the blackboard] by writing him up, and put him on the bench for 2 hours taking time-away.
    Yuko Mitsuka had a crappy life. She was being naughty during her stardom in golf and now she’s paying the price–a price too high to pay, we warn Mitsuka.
    Time-away is used to significantly decrease disruptive behavior. Corporal-punishment [the consequence with your hand] is used to significantly decrease disruptive behavior, as well as time-away–like taking their computer privileges away for a year. Writing them up when they’re being naughty by writing his name on the blackboard is just as effective as corporal-punishment and time-away.
    There are many disruptive behaviors that should have time-away or corporal-punishment or taking their computer or Goldfish privileges away for a year–not just tattling.
    mommies, never spoil your youth. They’ll be obnoxious and completely naughty.

    Reply
  49. 49
    Sakura98 says:

    This is not a proper word. Mommy doesn’t consider THIS tattling:
    Mommy! Stupid is a bad word!

    Reply

Trackbacks

See what others are saying about this post...
  1. I Should Have My Mouth Washed Out With Soap | Hey Lady! Whatcha Readin'? says:

    [...] writing this, I found a post where many parents (I assume) weighed in on the word stupid. I don’t think that stupid is a bad word…it’s all in the way your kid uses it, [...]

    Reply


We Appreciate Your Comments

Thank you for stopping by!
If you'd like an image next to your comment, you need a gravatar.